Does Planting by the Moon Really Work? Science vs Tradition

Planting by the moon phases, or lunar gardening, does align with the moon’s phases and astrological paths rather than traditional meteorological seasons. This practice has roots in ancient agricultural traditions and is based on the belief that the moon’s gravitational pull, which affects tides and water in the soil, also influences plant growth. Here’s a look at the reasoning behind it and what science says about its effectiveness.

Please note: Some links on Traum Homestead are Amazon links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission for sending you to Amazon. It costs you NOTHING extra. These links look like this. Your support through these links helps sustain the content and journey we share here. Thank you for being an integral part of Traum Homestead!

The Basic Principles of Lunar Gardening

Lunar gardening divides the lunar month into two primary phases:

1. Waxing Moon (New Moon to Full Moon):
   • This phase is associated with increased moisture in the soil as the moon’s gravitational pull on water increases.
   • The belief is that this upward pull stimulates leaf and stem growth, making it a favorable time for planting above-ground crops (e.g., lettuce, tomatoes).
2. Waning Moon (Full Moon to New Moon):
   • During this phase, gravitational pull is thought to be lower, and soil moisture is said to recede.
   • This period is considered best for root crops (e.g., carrots, potatoes) and for tasks like pruning, as it’s believed to encourage downward energy and root development.

Additionally, each lunar phase is associated with certain astrological signs (such as Cancer or Scorpio) thought to be favorable or unfavorable for different types of gardening tasks.

The Science Behind Lunar Gardening

The scientific evidence supporting lunar gardening is mixed, and most of it is based on indirect rather than direct influence:

1. Gravitational Pull on Water:
   • The moon’s gravity does influence tides significantly, but its effect on soil moisture is very minor and not strong enough to cause noticeable changes in water content within plants or soil. Unlike tides, soil moisture and groundwater are not impacted strongly enough by the moon’s gravitational pull to directly affect plant growth.
2. Light Cycles:
   • The increased moonlight during the full moon is thought to potentially impact plant behaviors, such as germination and flowering, especially in plants that are sensitive to photoperiods (daylight length). However, moonlight’s intensity is very low compared to sunlight, and scientific research has not conclusively linked this light to major effects on plant growth cycles.
3. Historical and Cultural Observations:
   • Many cultures observed plant growth cycles aligning with the lunar calendar, likely due to indirect patterns—such as warmer soil temperatures and seasonal rainfall that tend to coincide with certain lunar phases in specific climates. These observations could have created patterns over time that were beneficial but not causally linked to the moon’s phases.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Stay updated with the latest news, tutorials, and resources from Traum Homestead.

Please enter a valid email address.

Why People Still Use Lunar Planting

1. Tradition and Consistency:
   • Generations of gardeners and farmers have used the lunar calendar as a guide, especially in regions without modern agricultural resources. This tradition has become deeply ingrained in certain gardening communities.
2. Potentially Helpful Cyclical Patterns:
   • Even if not scientifically proven, the structure of planting by the moon phases creates a cyclical planting routine that may encourage gardeners to stay consistent and observant of their plants' needs.
3. Influence of Biodynamic Gardening:
   • Biodynamic farming, which includes lunar and astrological planting, has added credibility to moon-based gardening. Some biodynamic practices focus on working in harmony with natural cycles, including lunar phases, although its science-backed efficacy remains debated.

Does Planting by the Moon Work?

The scientific community has not found conclusive evidence that lunar gardening directly improves yields or plant health. However, because it creates a consistent routine and pattern of gardening practices, some gardeners report better results anecdotally, possibly due to increased observation and timing.

FAQ’s

You probably still have some lingering questions. Below we have addressed some of the most frequently asked questions to help fill in any gaps. Reviewing these FAQ’s will give you a deeper insight into some of the key aspects covered. If you still have questions feel free to let us know in the comment section below!

Does planting by the moon really improve crop growth?

Scientifically, there's limited evidence to support improved yields from moon-phase planting. However, it can create a rhythm and consistency in gardening, which can indirectly benefit plant care. Many gardeners report positive results, potentially due to their attentive observation and timely actions.

What’s the difference between planting during the waxing and waning moon?

The waxing moon (New Moon to Full Moon) is traditionally thought to encourage above-ground growth, making it ideal for leafy crops. The waning moon (Full Moon to New Moon) is believed to promote root growth, suitable for root crops like carrots and potatoes.

How can I get started with moon-phase gardening?

Begin by observing the moon phases and tracking them against your garden tasks. You can follow simple guidelines: plant leafy crops in the waxing moon phase, root crops in the waning moon, and use the Full Moon for pruning or weeding. Many gardening apps and lunar calendars also offer lunar phase tracking.

Summary

Lunar gardening is not scientifically proven to have a direct effect on plant growth but is rooted in tradition and offers a structured approach that some find helpful. If it aligns with a gardener’s rhythm and improves their consistency in planting, it can be a beneficial practice—even if the underlying mechanics remain unproven.

Additional Resources

Have more questions? Or if you want to dive further into the subject, check out these recommended resources.

Mother Earth News: HOMEGROWN Life: How to Schedule your Planting by the Moon - Dive further into the what and whens of lunar gardening.

Biodynamic Association Biodynamic Association - Explore their site for more information relating to biodynamics.

The Old Farmer’s Almanac Moon Calendar - This calendar offers a guide to planting based on moon phases for various regions.